Santa Claus Rally or Will The Grinch Win?

Gross Says Stocks Aren't Cheap

117th Edition of the Festival of Stocks

All Net-Nets Not Created Equal

162 Billion Reasons The Economy Will Improve In 2009

Why The Fed Truly Is ‘Going For Broke’

Why You Must Include Gold In Your Portfolio For 2009

TradeKing Discount Brokerage Review

Bonds: Here's the Glory

Stock Idea: CBS Corporation

Home

Subscribe   Subscribe to Value Investing News RSS feed  Subscribe to Value Investing News email newsletter

Value Investing News

Investor powered stock market news

Drop Down Menu

  • Login / Register
  • Submit Story
  • Review New Stories
    • Rising stories
  • Exclusives
  • Top Stories
    • This day
    • This week
    • This month
    • This year
    • All time
Home Story links Geoff's story links
  • Calendar
  • Forum
  • Videos
  • Help
  • Contact

Explore

  • Behavioral Finance
  • Bonds
  • Commentary
  • Digest
  • Education
  • Filings
  • Funds
  • International
  • Reviews
  • Shareholder Activism
  • Stock Analysis
  • Superinvestors
  • Tools
  • Stocks
  • Value Investing Forum
  • Videos
  • VIN Blog

Top Tickers

AIG AXP BAC BRKa BRKb C FRE GE GOOG GS HD JNJ KO MER MO MSFT PFE SHLD SNS TGT USG WFC WMT WU YHOO
more tags

Resources

  • Annual Report Delivery
  • Festival of Stocks
  • Jobs
  • Latest Annual Reports
  • Trade Publications
  • Value Directory

Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 29 guests online.

Online users

  • George
  • admin

User login

Login/Register
  • Create new account
  • Request new password

On the Mueller Mispricing: "A" Shares vs. "B" Shares

On the Mueller Mispricing: "A" Shares vs. "B" Shares

(via www.gannononinvesting.com)

A post on the price difference between Mueller Water Products (MWA) "A" shares and "B" shares. The shares are identical except that each A share has 1 vote and each B share has 8 votes. Right now, the B shares are selling for $0.34 a share less than the A shares despite having eight times the voting power (A shares: $13.98; B shares: $13.64)

Submitted by Geoff on Fri, 2007-04-06 03:24. | Tags:
  • Stock Analysis
  • MWA
  • MWAb
  • Login or register to post comments
  • 3 points

mwa vs mwa/b

Submitted by bingopitts on Fri, 2007-04-06 12:15.

I am glad that you read my post of the few days ago Mr Gannon about the price difference between MWA and MWA/B shares. Though you should have given me credit for the idea. Just kidding.

Seriously though, I find the price difference bizarre to say the least. There is NO rational reason to buy the A shares over the B. NONE!

If one does not think that it really matters on where to buy the voting over the non voting besides price then think back to the takeover of Resorts International. The voting shares got a higher price versus the non voting shares. If I was going to take over Mueller, I would buy the B shares and leave the non voting shares untouched. I would treat the A shares as publicly traded minority interest.

I can understand individual investors buying the A's over the B's. It could be they don't know that they exist, and that they did not do their homework. But for an institional investor to buy the A's over the B's, which happens everyday, I find unconscionable or maybe just plain STUPID.

Next time someone argues about the efficient market theory, point out the discrepancy in this stock, and ask if the market is efficient, why should this take place?

  • Login or register to post comments
  • 2 points

I Tried to Give You Credit But...

Submitted by Geoff on Fri, 2007-04-06 13:13.

Seriously, I remembered the comment was on Value Investing News, but couldn't remember where exactly it was. So, I used the search feature and couldn't find your comment. I'm sure the problem was with me and not the search feature – I probably used a term like "mwa.b" instead of "MWA/B" or something like that. Sorry.

But, getting to the efficiency question – this is a bit of a problem for the whole idea of market efficiency. Most of the really obvious big holes in the idea of efficiency can be said to only apply to smaller investors, because strategies like investing in reverse splits can blow the market away with little risk – but, the big boys can't get involved in anything that only pays cash on 99 shares. Likewise, oddly priced micro cap stocks can't be traded by the biggest investors.

But, Mueller isn't that small! Both of these shares are widely available. In fact, there are considerably more "B" shares than "A" shares. Of course, some big holders will want to keep the "B" shares out of the market now that they have a nice block for themselves – but, even so, there's enough volume in the "B" shares. No one needs to look only at the "A" shares – so, why is there a buyer for any of them right now?

It's like burning a pile of money. I wouldn't call it rational. You're paying extra to have your shares neutered. I don't see the logic behind it. Any institutional investor who touches the "A" shares while they trade at a premium should be made to account for egregious acts of idiocy.

  • Login or register to post comments
  • 2 points

If I understand correctly a

Submitted by random_walker on Tue, 2007-04-10 00:20.

If I understand correctly a similar situation exists between the IDTC (Class C) and IDT (Class B) shares. IDTC has 1 vote per share while IDT has 1/10 vote per share yet IDT trades at a premium to IDTC supposedly due to it being more liquid

  • Login or register to post comments
  • 1 point

liquidity and voting shares

Submitted by bingopitts on Tue, 2007-04-10 11:06.

Many stocks that have more votes trade at a lower price to the non voting shares due to liquidity. The ability of some investors to enter and leave a position with ease is worth some extra price to those investors.

However MWA/B has MORE shares outstanding and more liquidity than MWA, but still trades at a lower price.

  • Login or register to post comments
  • 1 point

Bruce Berkowitz owns over 10%

Submitted by bingopitts on Tue, 2007-04-10 12:40.

I see where Bruce Berkowitz of the Fairholme Fund has filed a 13-D on MWA. He now owns over 10% of Mueller Water. What shares did Mr Berkowitz buy? Why the MWA/B of course. Mr Berkowitz is no dummy.

  • Login or register to post comments
  • 1 point

Related News

  • Mueller Water Products: A Spin-off With Value
  • Gross Says Stocks Aren't Cheap
  • Stock Idea: CBS Corporation
  • Stock Analysis: Sovran Self Storage, Inc. (SSS)
  • AutoNation Inc.

Recent blog posts

  • November Contest Winners
  • Value Investing News for BlackBerry Addicts
  • November Contest - Fat Pitch Financials Contributor's Corner
  • October Contest Winners
  • October Contest - MagicDiligence
  • September Contest Winners
  • September Contest - The Four Filters Invention of Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger
  • August Contest Winners
  • New Feature: Value Investing News Calendar
  • August Contest - Even Buffett Isn't Perfect
more

Member Tools

  • Toolbar:
    Download Our Toolbar
    Packed with great investor tools, VIN headlines and quick story link submission.
  • Bookmarklet:
    Post to VIN
    Just right click on the bookmarklet link above and add it to your Favorites or drag it to your browser's toolbar. Then you can submit stories you find automatically with just one click.

52-Week Lows

  • RESEARCH IN MOTION L (RIMM)
  • GREY WOLF INC (GW)
  • U.S. OIL FUND ETF (USO)
  • POTASH CP SASKATCHEW (POT)
  • XENOPORT INC. (XNPT)
  • TESSERA TECHNOLOGIES (TSRA)
  • RIO TINTO PLC ADS (RTP)
  • CB RICHARD ELLIS GRP (CBG)
  • ANALOG DEVICES (ADI)
  • AEROPOSTALE INC (ARO)
  • AMERICAN CAPITAL STR (ACAS)
  • KELLOGG CO (K)
  • B C E INC (BCE)
  • ISIS PHARMACEUTICALS (ISIS)
  • SIERRA WIRELESS INC. (SWIR)
  • EXCEL MARITIME CARR (EXM)
  • PROSHARES TRUST (TBT)
  • ANNTAYLOR STORES CP (ANN)
  • ZALE CP (ZLC)
  • PENN REAL ESTATE TR (PEI)
  • DB COMMODITY IDX TRK (DBC)
  • PSYCHIATRIC SOLUTION (PSYS)
  • QUALITY SYSTEMS INC. (QSII)
  • ARBITRON INC (ARB)
  • NETEZZA CORPORATION (NZ)
  • UNION DRILLING INC. (UDRL)
  • IPATH ETN CRUDE OIL (OIL)
  • WUXI PHARMATECH ADS (WX)
  • ISLE OF CAPRI CASINO (ISLE)
  • WRIGHT MEDICAL GROUP (WMGI)
  • PIMCO CAL MUN INC II (PCK)
  • E W SCRIPPS CL A (SSP)
  • LINDSAY CORPORATION (LNN)
  • INVACARE CORP (IVC)
  • LA Z BOY INC (LZB)
  • QUAKER CHEM CP (KWR)
  • K V PHARMA CL A (KV.A)
  • XYRATEX LTD. (XRTX)
  • MANHATTAN ASSOCIATES (MANH)
  • DICE HOLDINGS INC (DHX)
  • PIMCO NY MUNI INC (PNF)
  • GULF ISLAND FABRICAT (GIFI)
  • ISHARES GSCI CMDTY (GSG)
  • NATIONAL GRID PLC (NGG)
  • COGDELL SPENCER INC (CSA)
  • PIONEER FLTG RT TRST (PHD)
  • ODYSSEY MARINE EXPLO (OMEX)
  • COLUMBIA BANKING SYS (COLB)
  • CHINA DIG TV HDG ADS (STV)
  • PROSH ULTRA DJ CRUDE (UCO)
  • CORVEL CORP. (CRVL)
  • MERCURY COMPUTER SYS (MRCY)
  • COINSTAR INC. (CSTR)
  • C C A INDS INC (CAW)
  • PLX TECHNOLOGY INC. (PLXT)
  • NXSTAGE MEDICAL INC. (NXTM)
  • PACHOLDER HI YLD FD (PHF)
  • SUN BANCORP INC. (SNBC)
  • BLUEGREEN CP (BXG)
  • C N A SURETY CP (SUR)
  • CITY BANK (CTBK)
  • SANDERS MORRIS HARRI (SMHG)
  • LIFETIME BRANDS INC. (LCUT)
  • SYMYX TECHNOLOGIES I (SMMX)
  • OMEGA PROTEIN CP (OME)
  • MITCHAM INDUSTRIES I (MIND)
  • CROSS TIMBERS ROYLTY (CRT)
  • QAD INC. (QADI)
  • OCEANFIRST FINANCIAL (OCFC)
  • MULTI-COLOR CORPORAT (LABL)
  • AB SVENSK MSCI ARN (MIS)
  • COLLECTORS UNIVERSE (CLCT)
  • SEACOAST BANKING COR (SBCF)
  • FIRST ACCEPTANCE CP (FAC)
  • AB SVENSK ROGERS ELE (RJN)
  • ALLIANCE BANKSHARES (ABVA)
  • NOBILITY HOMES INC. (NOBH)
  • UNIFY CORP (UNFY)
  • IPATH AIG GRAINS ETN (JJG)
  • IPATH GSCI TRI ETN (GSP)
  • MACROSHARES $100 OIL (UOY)
  • WCA WASTE CORPORATIO (WCAA)
  • MHI HOSPITALITY CORP (MDH)
  • GRAYMARK HEALTHCARE (GRMH)
  • SYNTHETIC FIXED 6.5 (GJD)
  • VIRAGE LOGIC CORPORA (VIRL)
  • STEWARDSHIP FINANCIA (SSFN)
  • CENTRAL VALLEY COMMU (CVCY)
  • ATLANTIC SOUTHERN FI (ASFN)

Annual Reports

  • Teekay LNG Partners L.P. 20-F/A
  • SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT 20-F
  • TANZANIAN ROYALTY EXPLORATION CORP 20-F
  • TERYL RESOURCES CORP 20-F
  • CONTINENTAL ENERGY CORP 20-F
  • SEMICONDUCTOR MANUFACTURING INTERNATIONAL CORP 20-F/A
  • ODYSSEY PICTURES CORP 10KSB
  • DESTINY MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES INC 10KSB
  • NEW CENTURY COMPANIES INC 10KSB/A
  • ABC Funding, Inc 10KSB/A
more

Search

Get News for:

Highest Users

UserPoints
George9
bsivia6
dbs1196
MurrayRothbard6
Dividend Growth...5
more

New forum topics

  • Happy Thanksgiving!
  • PG/SJM Folgers Spin off
  • Happy Halloween: Trick or Treat stock talk
  • Live Interview with the founder of MagicDiligence
  • Educational Resources
more

Recent comments

  • So true...
  • first Youtube.com video
  • Portfolio Investment Risk
  • Re:Wally Weitz on Berkshire Hathaway and Dell
  • I hear what you are saying

Brought to you by

One Share of Stock - buy one share of stock
buy payments
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2006 - 2008 Fat Pitch Financials LLC. All rights reserved.
RoopleTheme